A Guardian and a Thief Book Club Questions

By Book Club Ready · Practical ideas for your reading circle

These A Guardian and a Thief book club questions give your group 24 original prompts about Ma, Boomba, hunger, migration, family duty, and the difference between understanding a decision and excusing it. Start with questions 1 through 6 if anyone is still reading. Save the remaining questions, the two-family decision map, and the ending debate for a finished-book meeting.

Megha Majumdar sets the novel in a near-future Kolkata. Ma has secured visas to join her husband in Ann Arbor with her young daughter and elderly father, but her purse containing the immigration documents is stolen. Boomba takes it while trying to provide for his own family. The story follows both families through a single increasingly difficult week. The 2025 Knopf hardcover is 224 pages; pagination and format can differ, so ask members to identify a scene rather than insist on a page number.

Decide where spoilers begin

Questions 1 through 6 discuss only the publisher’s setup: the missing documents, two families, scarce food, and the one-week frame. They do not ask how the search ends. Full-book spoilers begin at question 7. After that point, members may discuss later crimes, character decisions, the families’ convergence, and the ending. If your group has mixed reading progress, run a short first meeting using only the opening set and schedule a second discussion after everyone finishes.

Spoiler-free opening questions

  1. What did the title make you expect from the words guardian and thief before you knew either family’s story?
  2. Why do the missing immigration documents carry more weight than the purse’s monetary value?
  3. How does the prospect of leaving Kolkata change Ma’s view of the city she is still living in?
  4. What does the one-week time frame do to your sense of which choices are possible?
  5. At what early moment did you become aware that food, time, and help are distributed unevenly?
  6. How does knowing Boomba’s family situation affect your first reaction to the theft without settling your judgment of it?

Questions about the two families

Full-book spoilers begin here. Ask members to give a specific moment for each answer. It is easy to turn this novel into a general argument about whether desperate acts are justified, while missing what a character actually knew at the time.

  1. What does Ma protect first when she discovers the documents are gone, and what does that priority cost her later?
  2. How does responsibility for her daughter differ from responsibility for her father in Ma’s decisions?
  3. Which of Boomba’s choices seems most understandable? Which becomes hardest to defend once its consequence is visible?
  4. How do the people around each family affect the options they can realistically consider?
  5. Where does a character mistake love for permission to decide on someone else’s behalf?
  6. If Ma and Boomba had met before the theft, what would each have recognised or misread in the other?

Questions about scarcity and moral judgment

  1. Which scene makes hunger feel like an immediate constraint rather than a distant social issue?
  2. When does a small advantage, such as information or a useful contact, become as valuable as money?
  3. Does the book ask readers to distribute blame differently as the week progresses? Name a point when your judgment changed.
  4. What is the difference between explaining Boomba’s theft through desperation and treating the theft as harmless?
  5. How would Ma’s position change if the documents could be replaced quickly? What does that counterfactual reveal about the system around her?
  6. Who has the power to wait, verify, or ask for help, and who has to act before knowing enough?

Questions about form and the ending

  1. How does moving between the two families shape your sympathy when one family’s gain becomes another family’s loss?
  2. Which scene would change most if narrated only through Ma’s viewpoint? Which would change most through Boomba’s?
  3. Does the compressed week make the ending feel inevitable, contingent, or both?
  4. By the final pages, who has acted as a guardian, and who has taken something from another person?
  5. Which unresolved question is most important to the novel’s meaning rather than simply to the plot?
  6. What single sentence would you use to describe the novel’s moral argument without calling either family entirely innocent or entirely guilty?

Run a two-family decision map

Draw two columns headed Ma and Boomba. For each, record one urgent need, one resource, one constraint, one decision, one person affected, and one fact the character did not know. Do the first pass before asking anyone whether the decision was right. This keeps cause, motive, and consequence separate. On the second pass, draw arrows when a choice by one family changes the other family’s options.

Use a third column headed institutions. Put the visa process, food access, transport, and other systems mentioned in the book there. The point is not to remove personal responsibility. It is to see which risks existed before either protagonist acted. If members disagree about a scene, ask them to quote or paraphrase the relevant action accurately before drawing a conclusion.

Try three short meeting activities

Make a one-week timeline

Give each member a sticky note for a turning point. Arrange notes by the novel’s week, then mark which events each family knows about. A chronology can expose how much readers know that the characters do not. Avoid using the timeline as a test of memory; consult the text when a sequence is disputed.

Hold a responsibility hearing

Choose one decision by Ma and one by Boomba. For each, assign one member to explain motive, another to describe harm, and a third to name a realistic alternative. Rotate roles for the second decision. Close by asking whether changed circumstances would alter the verdict. This works better than a simple vote on whether either character is good or bad.

Rename the novel

Invite each person to propose an alternate two-word title, then defend it with one scene. Compare the proposed titles with the published title: which reading becomes visible, and which disappears? This gives quieter members a compact entry point before the longer ending discussion.

A 90-minute meeting plan

Time Activity Host’s task
0-10 minutes Opening reaction and spoiler check Ask every member for one word or image
10-28 minutes Questions 7-12 Keep both families in view
28-48 minutes Questions 13-18 Request a concrete scene for each claim
48-65 minutes Decision map or responsibility hearing Separate motive, constraint, and harm
65-84 minutes Questions 19-24 Leave time for the ending
84-90 minutes Final thought and next-book choice Record the decision before people leave

For a 60-minute version, use questions 1, 7, 9, 14, 16, 19, 22, and 24. Write the selected questions into your meeting agenda, and use the printable planner to assign the opening, timekeeper, and follow-up roles.

Host a careful conversation about crisis

The novel includes hunger, climate-related disruption, crime, family peril, and anxiety about migration. You do not need members to share their own experiences of food insecurity or immigration. Offer an explicit pass option and keep the discussion anchored in what the novel depicts. Our ground rules can help a group disagree without turning someone’s personal circumstances into a debate exercise.

Some members will want to evaluate the theft immediately; others will focus on the conditions that precede it. Let both readings be heard, then ask what each overlooks. A useful follow-up is: who bears the cost when a reader spends several minutes defending a decision that a character had seconds to make? That question does not require consensus, but it clarifies the distance between reading and living through the fictional week.

Keep the discussion specific

Majumdar’s short time frame invites fast reading, but a strong meeting slows down at two or three small moments. Ask members to locate the first scene where they felt protective of Ma, the first where they understood Boomba, and the moment either feeling weakened. Record those moments side by side. You will get a more useful conversation than if everyone begins with an abstract answer to who deserves sympathy.

For a group that prefers open prompts, adapt our general discussion questions. If this was a difficult choice for some readers, use our book-selection process before voting on the next title. The facilitation guide has ways to bring quieter readers in without putting anyone on the spot.

Frequently asked questions

Are these questions spoiler-free?

Questions 1 through 6 stay with the setup. Questions 7 through 24 assume the entire novel has been read and include the ending.

How many questions should a small club use?

Choose eight to twelve for 90 minutes, including at least one from each full-book section. A lively answer can take longer than the schedule suggests.

Do members need the same edition?

No. Ask people to identify the day, character, or scene. The publisher lists several formats with different pagination.

Should the host reveal the publisher’s questions first?

Use the publisher’s guide as optional additional reading after your group has found its own questions. These prompts and activities are independently written.

The publisher’s book page verifies the premise, formats, author, and publication details. Its library page also links to an official discussion guide. This article does not reproduce those questions.

Get practical meeting guides and original discussion resources. Our tools remain free to use without subscribing.


← Explore more guides · Start your book club